Best Baseball Catcher’s Mitts

Best Baseball Catcher’s Mitts

November 18, 2021

Whether you are a pro or an amateur at baseball, you need to understand that a catcher’s mitt is a crucial break-in for best performance and protection during the game. Due to the wide range of responsibilities, catchers need the best mitts that will enable them to perform their duties without compromise. As a catcher, you do not need cheap gloves due to the risk and the pressure involved. You need to go for the top-quality products in the market.

In a market flooded with many catcher’s mitt and different brands, the selection process can be hectic; that is why this article exists. Reviewing the list of the top five catcher’s mitts saves your time during purchase and ensures you get the best deals.

#1. All-Star Pro-Elite Series 33.5″ Baseball Catcher’s Mitt

All-Star Pro-Elite Series 33.5″ Baseball Catcher’s Mitt

This catcher’s mitt is a top offering for those interested in quality and top standard baseball gloves. The catcher’s mitt is made from top-grade and quality Japanese tanned US steer hide. The leather products used in the manufacturing of the catcher’s mitt guarantee durability, and owners can use it for years before thinking of a replacement.

The catcher’s mitt is designed to ensure you can enjoy using it and is modified with an adjustable Velcro wrist strap to ensure it is friendly on the wrist. The finger hood has an additional protective layer to absorb shock from fast-moving balls and to ensure the thumb and other fingers are safe during the game.

Won by many Baseball pros and legends, it has a record for high performance and preference amongst baseball stars. Designed with performance in mind, it has an extended pocket useful for keeping the ball at your sight. They are designed with additional protective features to protect the players from the force generated by fast-moving balls or those thrown from long ranges.

The toe also enables the user to frame the pitch with more ease, and with a pocket that acts like a magnet, you can easily scoop the ball from the dirty pitch. The gloves are available in different sizes to fit the needs of different users. They come in 32-inch, 33.5-inch, and 35-inch, making them suitable for junior players such as high school baseball players.

The open back allows the wrist to move flexibly and the hands freely. The open back also ensures the hand receives sufficient air to stay active and freshly aerated during the game. It has a stiffer feel that allows it to hold the shape longer; however, it is difficult to break in during the first use; this changes after a few times using it.

Key Highlights:

  • Velcro straps
  • Japanese tanned steer hide
  • Open back


  • Durability
  • Available in multiple sizes
  • Extended pocket and profiled toe design


  • Hard to break-in
  • Expensive

#2. Rawlings HOH Hyper Shell 33″ Mitt

Rawlings HOH Hyper Shell 33″ Mitt

This is one of the most exclusive catcher’s mitts in the market. Made from the best and the most durable quality leather ever produced, this catcher’s mitt offers durability and protection beyond imaginable levels. The leather and the front protection elements can absorb shocks from throws of 85+.

The name is the selling point, “the Heart of the Hide,” and leathers guarantee quality for users. The interior is made using pro-grade laces and deer-tanned cowhide lining to make it smoother and friendly to the skin. The leather quality means you will require some break-in efforts; however, it will be good for the big game after a couple of games or a few hundred balls.

Despite having a 30% factory break-in, the catcher’s mitt is made from additional ultra-lightweight carbon fiber elements to make it light. It weighs 3.5 ounces, making it suitable to carry around, and you can put it on easily. The weight makes a difference during critical moments in the game, such as when you dearly need to apply a tag at home.

The thumb lopes are reinforced with additional protection against hard-throwing pitchers and improve comfort during the games. The comfort is also improved by using thermo-formed wrist linings that ensure the wrist stays comfortable during the game. The protective feature one-piece, solid webbing protects the palm and the back of the hand from any injuries.

Key Highlights:

  • Heart of the Hide
  • Ultra-lightweight carbon fiber elements
  • One-piece Solid webbing
  • Thermo-formed wrist linings


  • Durable
  • Comfortable
  • Lightweight


  • Only available in one size (size 34)
  • Designed for right hand throwing mitt only

#3. Wilson A2K Pudge 32.5″ Mitt

Wilson A2K Pudge 32.5″ Mitt

Wilson is one of the most accomplished companies manufacturing baseball gloves and mitts. Named after a prominent baseball player, Ivan “Purge “Rodriguez, this catcher’s mitt delivers the best performance due to various design features that make it stand out.

Manufactured from pro stock leather, the two-in-one combination catcher’s mitt guarantees you durability, a long-lasting shape before you think of a replacement. The best replacement for those who have used this glove before is buying the same catcher’s mitt. Unlike other premium and top-quality competitors, it offers a smooth break-in. There is no discomfort for the first few balls or first-time uses as you wait for it to adjust.

It has additional features such as 32.5 inches in circumference, extended palm, and widened webbing to offer the best performance. It also covers your other worries, such as protecting the thumb since it has a stiff thumb stall to keep the thumb in position while allowing it to move flexibly.

The catcher’s mitt is manufactured through the dual welting process to retain the shape, guarantee durability, and give an additional layer of protection and assurance. While playing, you are bound to have sweaty palms and hands; the sweat can sometimes be uncomfortable, especially on hot days or when removing the gloves. The interior is lined with Dri-Lex lining, which wicks the sweat and protects the palm from moisture.

It has an open back to give you more freedom for the hands and the wrist to move responsively. The half-moon web pattern creates deeper pockets suitable for catchers to secure fast-moving balls by creating a firm grip. The 33-inch size makes it suitable for high school and adult-sized players.

Key Highlights:

  • Dual welting process
  • Dri-Lex lining
  • Half-moon web pattern
  • Pro stock leather


  • Double durability
  • Smooth break-in
  • Comfortable and sweat control lining


  • Not available for left-hand throwers
  • Suppose you get a stiff one; you will need to break in

#4. Akadema AGC98 Catcher’s Mitt

Akadema AGC98 Catcher’s Mitt

It is a smaller glove than the traditional mitts; however, this should not worry. It has other cool features that make it offer improved performance and durability. It is made from materials to keep it light and durable.

It is made using polyurethane to guarantee durability and protection. Many players recognize it for the best feels due to the synthetic leather and shell made from Long Fiber Kip Leather to give a comfortable and prestigious feel.

The one-year warranty is a sign of quality, and the company guarantees an immediate refund within the first 30 days if you discover the product is defective. Another crazy offer and a sign of excellence is the 90-days return if you feel unsatisfied with the product.

Designed by the hall of Famer Gary Carter, it is one of the leading Cather’s mitts for youth players such as high school basketballers. It is ideal for smaller hands and offers the greatest value at affordable prices. It is also the best choice for adult catchers with smaller hands.

Akadema has incorporated various technologies into manufacturing to ensure the best performance and efficiency. The Akadema patent-pending stress wedge technology is placed between the index finger and the thumb to absorb all the potential shocks when receiving the ball.

The two additional finger hammocks allow them to stay firm and in position to create a tighter grip on the ball and prevent it from escaping. Designed to imitate the praying mantis position, the catcher’s mitt improves ball grasp and security. The spiral lock web pattern improves the catching support while ensuring the hand stays in the right position.

The 32 inches circumference catcher’s mitt does not discriminate since it is available for left and right-hand throwers. It is handcrafted using a US steer hide pocket and Akadema Lyte leather on the back to improve performance and durability.

Key Highlights:

  • The Akadema Patent-pending Stress Wedge technology
  • Two additional fingers hammocks
  • The spiral lock web pattern
  • US steer hide pocket and Akadema Lyte leather


  • Lightweight and durable
  • Additional protection
  • The stronger grip on the ball
  • Suitable for both left and right-hand throwers


  • It does not use the top quality leather

#5. Mizuno Prospect Series 33.5″ Mitt

Mizuno Prospect Series 33.5″ Mitt

It is ranked as one of the best catcher’s mitt for high school baseballs players and youths. It has a series of technologies incorporated to improve functionality. The Power close technology helps the junior or youth players to secure a good grip on the ball with less struggle and effort.

The power lock technology helps you easily remove and wear the gloves since the last two lops of the webbing are removed to ensure flexibility and ensure the gloves remain firm during the games. The gloves come with a PU Butter Soft Palm Liner to give it the soft touch to make it more comfortable to the hand while retaining durability.

The Mizuno’s exclusive Para shock Palm Pad ensures it can absorb more shock from fast-moving balls to protect the hands from injuries and reduce sting feeling when catching aggressive pitches. It is available for both right and left-hand throwers. It is made from soft laterite, making it easy to break in for instant use.

Key Highlights:

  • The Power close technology
  • Mizuno’s exclusive Para shock Palm Pad
  • PU Butter Soft Palm Liner
  • The power lock technology


  • Suitable for both right and left-hand throwers
  • Lightweight
  • Maximum protection


  • The leather is soft and loses shape quicker

Factors to Consider When Buying Baseball Catcher’s Mitts

Company reputation

According to many bass ballplayers and legends, the company determines the gloves’ durability and performance. Most companies manufacture quality and high-performance mitts; however, some give additional and extra features making their catcher’s mitt standout. You need to learn about the manufacturers before getting the products.


This should be the greatest consideration. The circumference of the glove determines the level of grip you have on the ball. You need to choose a middle size, not too tight or loose. The size should be comfortable for the hands and the wrist.

Get a catcher’s mitt sizing chart to help you with the selection. It determines the appropriate size based on factors such as age.


The material determines the durability and the level of protection offered by the mitts. The most reliable materials are leather gloves because they are durable, and the leather acts as additional protection from shocks and sting effects generated by the balls.

If you need light mitts, I advise you to consider those with additional carbon fiber elements or buy ones made from synthetic fibers. Soft leather gloves are comfortable to the hand; alternatively, you can buy those with comfortable interior linings.


You can choose either closed or open webbing; closed webbing is more durable than open. There are a few open webbings in the market, and you need to customize them based on your preference which can sometimes make them expensive.


The padding is the first line of defense for catchers when catching the ball. A weak amount of padding can hurt you in numerous ways; hence you need paddings with an additional layer of protection.


Based on the selection criteria, you should get the best catcher’s mitt to last you for months or years and improve your performance on the pitch. If you play professional and adult league bass ball, the All-Star Pro-Elite Series, Rawlings HOH Hyper Shell 34″ Mitt, or Wilson A2000 Pudge 32.5″ Mitt should be a desirable and reliable pick.

Akadema AGC98 Catcher’s Mitt or the Mizuno Prospect Series 32.5″ mitt will be the best pick for youths and high school baseball players. Once you secure either of these, you can forget about the worries of having to budget for another mitt. After the break-in, you are good to go.