Best Baseball Eye Black

Best Baseball Eye Black

January 3, 2022

Eye black for baseball players is very important for reducing glare, regardless of whether it’s a super sunny day or the stadium lights are just too bright. When playing this sport, you need to be able to see everything going on and these products can help you make that happen. They usually come in both strips and grease, both of which have advantages and disadvantages.

The issue comes when you realize that there are hundreds of products and it can be difficult to find the best one for you. In addition to providing five of the best baseball eye black products, we’ve also included a short buying guide and FAQ section to give you all of the information you need.

Each of the five reviews have a thorough summary, pros, and cons, so all of the important information is gathered in one place. With that said, let’s dive in and take a look at the top five best eye black products for baseball players!

#1. EASTON PRO Eye Black


Our first eye black product is the Easton PRO eye black. If you’ve been playing baseball for a while, you know that Easton is one of the best brands and they produce high-quality products. It’s anti-smear and will stay on your skin even when you’re sweating and wiping your face. The anti-glare properties make it a great option for those sunny days or bright nights playing under the stadium lights. This is essential because being able to see what’s going on could be the difference between winning and losing the game.

Another great thing about this product is that it won’t melt on hot days, which means you can play your game without worrying about the eye black running down your cheeks. The tube itself looks just like a lipstick and is around the same size, so you can carry it pretty much anywhere. It’s easy to apply and can be removed with a wet washcloth or wet wipe. If it gives you any trouble, you can add a little bit of mild soap to make removal much easier.

This Easton product can be used for both children and adults, which means it’s a great product for literally everyone. This is the product for those that want a long-lasting application while still having plenty of product to last the entire season.


  • Anti-glare.
  • Anti-smear.
  • Non-toxic.


  • Stains clothing.

#2. Franklin Sports Eye Black

Franklin Sports Eye Black

The next product on our list is the Franklin Sports eye black strips. This product comes as stickers that you stick right to your skin and they are a bit different than other options because the included white pencil means you can customize them and write anything you want on them. They have great anti-glare properties that mean you can play the best game you can without worrying about not being able to actually see what’s going on.

In addition to the white pencil, you’ll get 24 stickers in the pack. While you’ll use two stickers at each game, they can be reapplied. This means each pack can last for up to 24 games. With that said, though, those that sweat quite a bit might find that the stickers only last for one game and can’t be reapplied. Another great thing about these stickers is that they are super versatile and will work well for both children and adult players. Another awesome thing is that it works well for those with sensitive skin because it’s just a sticker.

If you’re looking for something that you can customize and don’t have to worry about smearing, then this is the product for you. It might take a little practice to get the stickers applied correctly, but it can work great for your needs.


  • Long-lasting.
  • Multi-use.
  • Great for sensitive skin.


  • Possible application difficulties.

#3. Wilson Black Eye Stick

Wilson Black Eye Stick

Wilson is another one of those brands that are super well-known in the baseball community. They are known for making high-quality products and this eye black is no different. It’s also super easy to use and a few swipes under each eye will have you ready to play the best game that you can.

Like some of the other options on this list, this product looks exactly like a tube of lipstick and it’s used the same way. Remember, though, the stick can break if you push too hard, so try and apply with caution. The formula that’s used has a lot of fantastic properties, like it being non-toxic, which makes it great for those with sensitive skin.

In addition to being non-toxic, this product is also anti-glare, non-smearing, and waterproof. These features make it great for pretty much everyone and can really make a difference during your game. While the stick is smaller than some other options, there should be plenty of product to last throughout the entire season. As long as you use it correctly and always put the cap back on, there’s a good chance that it can last some of the next season too!


  • Awesome anti-glare properties.
  • Waterproof and sweatproof.
  • Easy to use tube.


  • Smaller stick with less product.
  • Multiple swipes might be needed.

#4. BlackEye Black Grease

BlackEye Black Grease

Our next eye black product is called BlackEye Black Grease. While the formula of this item is non-toxic, it’s more grease-based than other options on this list. This can cause some people to break out, but it’s one of the most durable and affordable options available.

Additionally, it stays in place through sweating and rain, which is essential during those hot summer days. After application, you’ll want to give the grease plenty of time to dry before playing to ensure that it stays where you placed it for a longer amount of time.

Instead of looking like a tube of lipstick, this product looks like a glue stick. You use it the same way and put a couple of swipes under each eye and you’re ready to play once dry! The great thing is that you can put the grease in pretty much any shape you want, which brings another level of customization to your game days.

It’s anti-glare and comes in a small enough tube that you can fit it pretty much anywhere. There’s plenty of grease included in the container and you should be able to use it throughout your entire season.


  • High-quality formula.
  • Smear-proof.
  • Anti-glare.


  • Possible irritation for sensitive skin.

#5. Franklin Sports Football Eye Black

Franklin Sports Football Eye Black

The final item on our list is the Franklin eye black. The formula is non-toxic and can be easily applied in a matter of seconds. In addition, it has fantastic anti-glare properties that really help cut down on the amount of glare you get during the game.

While there could be smearing, you should find that the paint stays on your face. You can easily apply the product by doing a few swipes under each eye and removal is just as easy. You can use a warm washcloth or wet wipe and adding soap can remove any stubborn leftover paint.

The product itself is made from beeswax, which makes it a fantastic option for those that have sensitive skin. It also makes it a good choice for children because it doesn’t have any toxic ingredients. This is also another reason why it only smears but doesn’t get removed from your skin.

One thing to remember, though, is that beeswax does melt. If you’re playing for several hours underneath the hot sun or hot stadium lights, you might find that the product starts to break down. With that said, this still shouldn’t cause the eye black to get completely removed from your face and you should still be able to avoid most of the glare from the sun or lights.


  • Easy to apply.
  • Great for sensitive skin.
  • Durable.


  • Possible smearing.

Buying Guide

Getting the best product for your money can be difficult because there are so many choices. We’ve put together a quick buying guide to help you find the product that will meet your needs.

For starters, you want to consider if the product is anti-glare. You don’t want to try and catch a ball with a glare in your eyes. Not only will you be able to see better, but your teammates won’t see a glare when they look at you.

You’ll also want to think about ease of application. Some products, like stickers, can be difficult to apply and sometimes have issues staying in place. Sticks, on the other hand, can be put on in a matter of seconds.

Another consideration is the formula used in the product. Not only do you want to avoid any harmful ingredients, but it might be beneficial to find something with moisturizing properties. Look at all of the ingredients before making your purchase.

The type of eye black you want is another thing to think about. Some people prefer the stickers, while others want a stick that can glide across their skin. Both have benefits and disadvantages, so you’ll want to think about your personal needs.

One last thing you should think about is the paint’s durability. Not only is it important that the paint holds up through anything, but it’s also important that you don’t have to buy multiple ones throughout the season.

Our Top Pick

While all of these eye black products are great options, our top pick is the Wilson Eye Stick. Not only does it have anti-glare properties to ensure you can see while playing, but it’s both sweatproof and waterproof. The stick itself looks like a lipstick container and a few swipes is all it takes. It’s also non-toxic, which means it’s a fantastic option for those with sensitive skin. The final reason why this product is at the top of our list is because there are so many happy customers and it comes highly recommended!


Take a look below to see the answers to some of the most frequently asked questions that we get.

Q: How do I remove eye black?

A: You can remove the product by using a wet wipe or wet washcloth. If it’s giving you difficulties, adding a little soap usually does the trick.

Q: Will it smear if I sweat or rub my face?

A: Most of these products are both sweatproof and waterproof, so you shouldn’t have to worry about smearing.

Q: Will it cause skin changes?

A: Many eye black companies will create formulas that help make it easier on the skin, but those with sensitive skin might notice some changes.

Q: Does it come in other colors besides black?

A: Yes! You can get these in almost any color!

Q: How many uses will I get from this product?

A: Most of the time, you’ll be able to use the same product throughout the entire season. There are some cases, though, when you’ll get more or less uses.

Final Verdict

Baseball eye black is a great product that can really help players play a better game. Not only are most anti-glare, but they’re also usually smear-free. They come in multiple different application types and you can easily find ones with non-toxic and safe formulas.

To find the best product for your needs, consider what we said above and let the buying guide help you make your purchase. Try out a few on the list and find your favorite product to have a fantastic season!